Monday, April 14, 2014

Nothing Can Possibly Go Wrong

Nothing-coverIn line with ABCWednesday's "N" Week, I want to share with you are "nifty" graphic novel "Nothing Can Possibly Go Wrong" by Prudence Shen and Faith Erin Hicks (First Second 2013).
Honoring Women’s History Month, we highlight a wonderful young adult book that is written by women about bending stereotypes, Nothing Can Possibly Go Wrong by Prudence Shen and Faith Erin Hicks (First Second Books, 2013).

Nothing Can Possibly Go Wrong is a graphic novel for older kids (for mature middle school or high school and older) adapted and drawn by Faith Erin Hicks from the young adult novel Voted Most Likely by Prudence Shen. It’s full of unlikely friendships and nicely nuanced characters who bend and shatter stereotypes and expectations.

The central characters are Charlie Nolen, captain of Hollow Ridge High School basketball team and his (best) friend Nate Harding, president of the robotics club.

Prudence Shen and Faith Erin Hicks (First Second, 2013)
In a twist of fate, the robotics club and the cheerleaders are vying for student council funding. Charlie, a science Geek decides that the best way to guarantee getting those funds is for him to run for student council president.

The “Gestapo” cheerleaders decide to have Nate (Charlie's best friend and the ex-boyfriend of on of the "Gestapo" captains) run against him with the hopes that they can manipulate Nate into funding their new outfits and not the robotics club. And while each group is convinced that their strategies are flawless, things don’t work out the way anyone had planned.

The book is all about friendships, cooperation, heartbreak, and the myopic pursuit of goals versus creative thinking. Along the way, there are break-ups, disappointments, and lots of fun.
Prudence Shen and Faith Erin Hicks (First Second, 2013)
Aside from the interesting story weaving high school basketball, cheerleading, and robot rumbles, it’s the nuanced characters that really make Nothing Can Possibly Go Wrong fun and different. And these characters are developed both in the text and in the way they’re drawn, dressed, and artfully designed. Each and every one of them is full of contradictions that empower them to bend and break their stereotypic roles along with the reader’s expectations.

The popular jock gives into his unhappiness; the nerd flips between being sympathetic and manipulative while being blindly driven. The cheerleaders are kick-ass Machiavellian but not at all shallow. They, like the nerd, are focused in their efforts to reach their goals. And then there’s the cute Joanna, who is one ruthless robot driver, welder, and science geek who helps Charlie find his way again.

Prudence Shen and Faith Erin Hicks (First Second, 2013)

The book opens with Nate giving Charlie a lift home from school. Charlie has just received a text from Holly (Cheerleader Co-Captain), breaking up with him. Nate, meanwhile, is blindly focusing on how upset he is at finding out that Holly and “her evil fembot co-captain Nola” want to take funding from the robotics competition to fund new cheerleader uniforms. Principal Getty has just decided to let the student council decide who gets the available funds: the cheerleaders or the robotics club.

As Nate meets with his robot team to tell them the news, it's then he decides the answer is for him to run  for student council president. While his fellow teammates try to convince him that the election is merely a popularity contest he can’t possibly win, Nate is absolutely determined and convinced that nothing can possibly go wrong.

When Charlie decides to run for student council president and the Cheerleaders nominate Nate, some serious negative politics and ploys ensue.  They're so negative in fact, that Principal Getty informs BOTH teams that they went too far and as a result have been dropped from any possible school funding.

Prudence Shen and Faith Erin Hicks (First Second, 2013)
Prudence Shen and Faith Erin Hicks (First Second, 2013)
At this point, Joanna (a very cute fellow robot geed), just wants to knock the crap out of Nate. But, “the twins” (two other robot teammates whose names we only learn at the end of the book), have a more productive idea: They suggest that they might get funding by competing and winning a “Robot Rumble” that takes place on Thanksgiving. First and second places will win them a ton of money that will more than meet their funding needs for the robotics club.

There are two minor problems with this idea. First, the Robot Rumble involves robots tearing each other apart. IF they don’t win — and even if they do win — their robot may be seriously damaged, if not totally disabled. Second, they don’t have enough funds to reinforce “The Beast” (their robot) from possible rumble damage or to even enter the rumble itself.

Prudence Shen and Faith Erin Hicks (First Second, 2013)
Meanwhile, while dealing with his mom’s leaving, his parents subsequent divorce, and his mom’s recent announcement of her engagement to another man, Charlie comes up with a solution for his friends: have the cheerleaders invest in The Beast. If The Beast were to win, there’d be more than enough prize money to fund both the robotic teams’ entry and trip to the Robot Competition AND fund the cheerleaders’ new uniforms. IF, of course, The Beast were to win the rumble.
The rest of the story is up to you to read and enjoy.

In short, Nothing Can Possibly Go Wrong is about friendship, dirty politics, rumbling robots, basketball, cheerleading, and family. In addition to wonderfully nuanced characters and the wacky bending of expectations and stereotypes, the story relays:
Prudence Shen and Faith Erin Hicks (First Second, 2013)
  • That there is more to the simple stereotypes of Jocks, Geeks, Nerds, Cheerleaders (to name a few);
  • The power of friendship, especially when things get tough;
  • How dirty, even in high school, politics can become;
  • The power of persistence and cooperation with others to achieve your goals;
  • That navigating social hierarchies takes skill and insight;
  • Popularity does not insure happiness; and
  • Anyone can be bullied and anyone can be a bully.

Cultural Diversity, Civic Responsibilities, and Social Issues
  • Define stereotypes your students come across in their lives. Discuss the pros and cons of using stereotypes and why they persist.
  • Have the class describe/define social labels such as “Nerds,” “Jocks,” and Geeks,” and analyze how the characters in this book comply with and defy these definitions and expectations. Talk about how these expectations might be used and misused in your school.
  • Discuss and define typical male and female roles and expectations. Analyze how the book’s characters meet and defy these expectations, and why.
  • Follow and discuss how both sides effectively and ineffectively campaigned for student council president, making sure to include their use of posters, slogans, and strategies. Discuss how their approaches were similar and different to those of local political campaigns in your area.
Prudence Shen and Faith Erin Hicks (First Second, 2013)

Language, Literature, and Language Usage
  • Search for, and discuss the book’s use of alliteration, simile and metaphor. Discuss how these literary tools help the authors relay details and nuances in the story’s characters and plot.
  • Discuss the derogatory words the kids use to describe others (i.e. “Gestapo cheerleaders,” “hoochie-forms,” and “evil fembot co-captain,” to name a few).
  • Discuss why your students think the twins were not given names until the end of the book. How did this affect the story and the way we perceive them?
  • Chart and analyze the slogans used by Nate and by the cheerleaders. Discuss how they help and/or hurt their political positions.
  • Discuss the various team and robot names at the Robot Rumble. Have students discuss team and robot names they would use and why.
Critical Thinking and Inferences
The authors make many inferences in this book both with language use and through imagery. You may want to discuss the following uses of inference:
  • This book is all about navigating socially in high school. Have students come up with their own “handbooks” or unofficial social rules of high school (or middle school depending on the age/grade of your students).
  • Charlie’s solution for both teams’ financial issues is for the cheerleaders to invest in The Beast in the hope that The Beast places first and the prize money they receive will more than pay for the respective teams’ needs. Discuss and evaluate the risks versus the benefits of this strategy. Would you do it?
  • There are a number of political/historical references made by Nate regarding the cheerleaders. Find and discuss them. (For example: On page 28, Nate tells Charlie, “You’re such a mess. They’re cheerleaders, not the KGB.”)
  • After going too far and destroying the football field, Holly tells Principal Getty, “What we did was in extremely poor judgment and taste, but we were obeying the spirit of the electoral process.” Discuss the inferences and implications of this statement and how they were or were not “obeying the spirit of the electoral process.”
Modes of Storytelling and Visual Literacy
In graphic novels, images are used to relay messages with and without accompanying text, adding additional dimension to the story. Compare, contrast, and discuss with students how images can be used to relay complex messages. For example:
Prudence Shen and Faith Erin Hicks (First Second, 2013)
  • Discuss how posters are designed and then used during the campaign. Analyze the images as well as the choice of words and slogans.
  • On page 50, Nate says to Charlie, “Breathe. I hardly think the Pom-Pom Gestapo can do anything to you. Discuss the author’s choice of words and the imagery they relay. Then search the book and see how the illustrations further relay this image.
  • To get to the Robot Rumble, Charlie, Nate, Ben, Joanna, the twins, Holly, and Nora drive from Hollow Ridge to Atlanta. On pages 196-197, we are told that the kids “argued vociferously (for 15 minutes) about the best way to get onto the highway.” Using various maps (NOT on the computer), plot how you might drive. Discuss where you might stop and why.
  • Discuss the effective design of the Robot Rumble poster. Make sure to include the use of font, the use of the space and the choice of images used. How effective were these choices?
Prudence Shen and Faith Erin Hicks (First Second, 2013)
Suggested Prose and Graphic Novel Pairings
For greater discussion on literary style and/or content here are some prose novels and poetry you may want to read with The Silence of Our Friends
  • The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins — a story about Katniss Everdeen, a strong young woman who defies stereotypes.
  • Friends with Boys by Faith Erin Hicks — for high school readers, a story about missing mothers, distant brothers, high school, and new friends.
  • The Adventures of Superhero Girl by Faith Erin Hicks — about a superhero girl who loves kittens and battles monsters and the mundane.
  • I’d Tell You I Love You, But Then I’d Have to Kill You (Gallagher Girls Series) by Ally Carter — about Carrie Morgan, a sophomore at an elite spy-training school who has no idea what to do when she meets an ordinary guy who thinks she’s ordinary as well.
  • The Outsiders by S.E. Hinton — a story about the social divisions among kids and the mechanisms that drive their rivalry.
  • The Chocolate War by Robert Cormier — a story about a kid who defies social convention in his school and the subsequent fallout from his actions.
  • American Born Chinese by Gene Luen Yang — a graphic novel that explores stereotypes and adolescent worries over perception and acceptance.
  • The Absolutely True Story of a Part Time Indian by Sherman Alexie — about a bright motivated young Native American who must decide between a long commute to a better all-white school off the reservation (and face ridicule from white kids he must befriend and from his local friends he leaves behind) or to remain with his friends at the reservation’s  limited high school and head nowhere fast.
For more details on this book and its characters, as well as further book club and classroom uggestions (and how they meet Common Core State Standards) please see Using Graphic Novels in Education: Nothing Can Possibly Go Wrong.

In the meantime, thanks for your visit and please leave your reactions in the comments below.


  1. Sounds interesting! Great review!

  2. Seems like a NICE book for my daughter.